My Island Ice Cream - 70 Flavors of Happiness in Merritt Island

Located at 110 S Courtenay Pkwy in Merritt Island, FL, My Island Ice Cream is a delightful local gem that has quickly become the go-to spot for ice cream enthusiasts craving a truly authentic and indulgent experience. This charming ice cream shop stands out not only for its remarkable selection of 70 distinct flavors but also for the warm, welcoming atmosphere crafted by owners Anthony and Erin, whose passion for their craft shines through with every scoop.

The variety here is astonishing—ranging from classic favorites like rich, chunk-filled chocolate to innovative options such as Baja chocolate, and even lactose-free and sugar-free choices, ensuring everyone can indulge guilt-free. Whether you prefer a waffle cone with fresh, crisp texture or a creamy, hand-dipped bowl, My Island Ice Cream delivers on both quality and flavor. Customers frequently rave about their generous scoop sizes and the vibrant, tongue-tingling shakes, malts, and even pup cups for furry friends.

Walking into My Island Ice Cream, you’re greeted immediately with genuine smiles and heartfelt appreciation, making each visit feel like catching up with old friends. The interior strikes a perfect balance between quaint charm and inviting fun vibes—an ambiance that effortlessly lifts your spirits alongside your delicious treat. Convenience is also a highlight here, with ample parking right outside and a restroom inside, complementing the outstanding service.

Real visitors speak volumes about the experience: Micah Savell praises the store’s transformation, emphasizing the “BEST Ice cream” served with sincerity and joy. C C appreciates the fresh waffle cones and the welcoming staff that makes the treat even sweeter. Stephanie B. was enthralled by the creamy, chunk-loaded chocolate that redefined her expectations of what real ice cream should be. TJ Taylor highlights the fun atmosphere and hearty cone sizes, while Sara Fellows wishes she lived next door just to enjoy it daily, calling the ice cream “regret free” despite the indulgence.

For those who delight in savoring more than just ice cream, My Island Ice Cream’s make-your-own soda concoctions, like the refreshing mix of Sprite, mango puree, and half & half sampled by Steven Ryan, add a playful twist to the traditional ice cream shop experience.

Whether you're a local or just passing through Merritt Island, My Island Ice Cream promises a heartfelt, flavor-packed visit. It's not just an ice cream shop—it’s a vibrant community spot where every scoop tells a story of quality, care, and joy. You’re not just getting a dessert here; you’re partaking in a beloved local tradition that’s truly only gotten better with time.

Has wheelchair-accessible car park
Has wheelchair-accessible entrance

Has in-store shopping
On-site services available
Offers takeaway
Serves dine-in
No delivery
No same-day delivery

Good for solo dining

Accepts credit cards
Accepts debit cards
Accepts NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Micah Savell

05/12/2025

Boy, oh boy. The changes Anthony and Erin have made are outstanding. They are serving the BEST Ice cream and serving it with a smile and genuine appreciation for your business. 70 flavors of ice cream, pup cups, shakes, malts. It just AWESOME, you gotta try it. Still the best..... only better!

C C

28/11/2025

First the ice cream is absolutely delicious. I got the Baja chocolate in a waffle cone. It was super good and the waffle cone was fresh. Second the employees were very sweet and welcoming. As soon as we walked in we were greeted with a smile. We will definitely be back!

Stephanie B.

20/11/2025

Wow! A REAL ice cream store- that serves REAL ice cream!! Treated right away and told that the cooler was not the only ice cream available- there was a menu board with ALL the flavors- 76 today! I got a 2 scoop bowl- 1 coconut and one chocolate. The chocolate was on top and it was loaded with chunks of chocolate in a rich, creamy base. It was so satisfying that I should have stopped there- but I had to try the coconut. Oh man!! This was the best coconut that I have ever had. It was beyond creamy with many, many bunches of coconut. The atmosphere was relaxed island theme with assorted candies and other items for purchase. New find- will definitely be back!

TJ Taylor

03/11/2025

I am visiting a friend and she took me to this quaint local store on Merritt Island. The atmosphere inside is fun with good vibes. I had a cone with 2 scoops of ice cream. The scoops were huge and the ice cream was delicious. There is parking right outside the door and they have a restroom inside.

Sara Fellows

14/10/2025

So happy to find this place! It's so good that if I lived on the next street, I'd be over here every day, even in the winter!! I'd give it 10 stars if I could! Their prices are less than others & their hand dipped ice cream is better! They have so many flavors, 70 to be exact, that it's hard to choose. Some are Lactose free & some are sugar free. But they are ALL regret free! They'll even give you a sample to help you make your mind up! The owners, Micah & Sharon are super friendly and on the ball. You definitely have to try My Island Ice Cream; in front of T-J Max!

Steven Ryan

26/08/2025

We were greeted immediately with a smile. Everyone we interacted with was super friendly. I had a make your own soda; Sprite, mango puree, and half and half. It was delicious!

Casey

19/08/2025

Super Friendly Staff, Unique Interior, 70 Delicious Flavors! I discovered My Island Ice Cream by accident while stopping at the Publix nearby. The interior is a pleasant surprise. I've included pictures so that you can see for yourself! The staff are super friendly and considerate. I truly believe they would have let me sample all 70 ice cream flavors if I'd asked. The Dark Raspberry and Butterscotch flavors were to die for, and all four people in my party got something that had them sighing, "YUMMMMM!" I've been a Google Reviewer for some time now and never seen an ice cream shop with over 300+ reviews at a 5 out of 5 star rating. Tasting is believing, and this ice cream tastes amazing--but that 5-star rating is due to more than just the product. The environment and the staff make My Island Ice Cream what it is. This place is worthy of your patronage. Treat your sweet tooth--and your soul--to a bit of goodness! We'll be back :D